Risk & claims

Cargo claims in project logistics: prevent the damage, then protect the paper trail

by · · 6 min read

The best cargo claim is the one you never have to file. On heavy lift and module moves, damage rarely comes out of nowhere. It usually starts weeks earlier: a vague packing specification, a lashing plan nobody checked, or a receipt signed without looking. And when damage does happen, the outcome of the claim depends less on the dent itself than on what was recorded at each handover.

In this article I share how I approach cargo damage on EPC projects: first how to prevent it, then what to do in the first hours when it happens anyway.

Why damage on project cargo is different

A damaged pallet of general cargo is an insurance file. A damaged module, reactor or transformer is a schedule problem. Many project items are one-offs with long lead times, so repair or replacement can push critical path activities on site. That is why prevention and fast, well-documented handling matter far more than the claim amount alone.

Project cargo also passes through many hands: the vendor, an inland haulier, a terminal, a heavy-lift or semi-submersible vessel, a discharge port, a laydown area and finally the construction team. Every one of those handovers moves responsibility, and often risk, from one party to the next.

Where damage usually starts

Prevention: five habits that pay off

  1. Put packing and preservation requirements in the purchase order and inspect before release from the vendor works. Changing a crate in the factory is cheap; changing it on the quay is not.
  2. Treat sea fastening as engineering. Calculations, drawings and, where the insurance requires it, approval by the marine warranty surveyor before the vessel sails.
  3. Hold a joint inspection at every handover. Both parties present, dated photos, and a short report signed by both.
  4. Write remarks on the document itself. On the delivery receipt, mate's receipt or CMR consignment note, not in an email afterwards.
  5. Agree upfront who notifies whom. The Incoterms, the EPC contract and the insurance policy decide who carries the risk at each stage. Put the notification chain in your Logistics Execution Plan.

When damage happens: the first hours

The first hours after discovery decide a large part of the outcome. My checklist:

Know your notice periods. As an example: under the Hague-Visby Rules, written notice of loss or damage is due at delivery, or within three days if the damage is not apparent, and legal action must generally be brought within one year. Under CMR for international road transport, apparent damage must be noted at delivery and non-apparent damage within seven days (Sundays and public holidays excepted). Charter parties and project contracts often contain their own terms, so read them before the cargo arrives, not after.

Build it into the Logistics Execution Plan

None of this works if it depends on one alert person on the quay. Make it part of the plan: inspection points per handover, a standard inspection form, who attends, how photos are stored and named, the notification chain with contact details, and the notice periods per contract. Then the team knows what to do at 2 a.m. when a module arrives with a scratch that may or may not be just a scratch.

Without a clean record of where the damage happened, you end up negotiating with opinions instead of facts. That is a long meeting.

This article gives general practical guidance and is not legal advice. Always check the applicable contracts, conventions and insurance conditions for your project.

Frequently asked questions

How quickly must I notify the carrier of cargo damage?

It depends on the contract and the convention that applies. Under the Hague-Visby Rules, written notice is due at delivery, or within three days if the damage is not apparent. Under CMR (international road transport), apparent damage must be noted at delivery and non-apparent damage within seven days, Sundays and public holidays excepted. Charter parties and contracts can set their own terms, so check them before the cargo arrives.

Who is responsible for cargo damage on an EPC project?

That follows from the Incoterms in the purchase orders, the EPC contract, the transport contracts and the insurance set-up. The point where risk passes is also the point where a clean handover record matters most.

Should I sign a delivery receipt when the cargo looks damaged?

You can sign for receipt, but write specific remarks on the document itself describing what you see, and take dated photos. A clean signature without remarks makes it much harder to show later where the damage happened.

← All articles

An EPC or heavy-lift project coming up?

I help owners and EPC contractors with logistics strategy, shipping tenders and execution all the way to site. As interim manager or adviser.

Get in touch Call Gert